FRENCH HOSTAGES TO DIE TIT FOR TAT
Paris, Occupied France • September 28, 1941
On this date in 1941, in the wake of the first public assassination of a German officer in France, the German military authorities issued a Code of Hostages to the French people. Pools of Frenchmen, whether detained by French authorities or by the German Wehrmacht (armed forces) or the Gestapo (secret police) for “anti-German” and otherwise illegal activities, were to be held in readiness as hostages against future attacks on German soldiers. Illegal activities included espionage, sabotage, armed attacks, and distributing anti-German tracts. Fifty to 100 Frenchmen would be shot for every German killed. German authorities went so far as to paste affiches rouge (red and black posters) on public walls replete with mug shots and names of “criminals,” “bandits,” “foreigners,” “terrorists,” and others they had arrested, tortured, and executed in prisons near and within Paris, the occupied French capital. Members of the French Resistance responded with their own wall posters: “For every patriot shot, 10 Germans will be killed.”
It was open season on both sides for the rest of the war. In one of the most gruesome reprisals—this on June 9, 1944, in the French industrial town of Tulle in Central France—a Waffen-SS (Armed Schutzstaffel) battalion of the Der Fuehrer Regiment, part of the elite 2nd SS Panzer Division “Das Reich,” together with members of the Sicherheitsdienst (the Nazi Party’s intelligence agency), first tortured, then murdered 99 randomly selected men aged between 17 and 42, hanging the victims’ bodies from trees, balconies, and lamp posts all over town. According to the Waffen-SS battalion commander, the lethal reprisal avenged a kidnapping and the killing of 40 German soldiers by members of the French Resistance intent on hindering the division’s race from Southern France to Normandy, 450 miles/724 km away, to throw back the Allied landings there (Operation Overlord). Topping off the killings, another 321 captives were sent to labor camps in the Third Reich, where 101 lost their lives. In total, the actions of the Germans claimed the lives of 213 Tulle civilians. The next day, June 10, the same Waffen-SS warriors massacred 642 inhabitants, including women and children, in the farming village of Oradour-sur-Glane, 15 miles/24 km north of Tulle. (It was discovered later that there were no résistants in Oradour-sur-Glane; some members of “Das Reich” considered it funny that they had murdered the wrong inhabitants.)
Marshal Philippe Pétain, the octogenarian head of the collaborationist Vichy government, appealed to his countrymen for restraint, saying that by terms of the Franco-German armistice of June 22, 1940, Frenchmen had agreed to lay down their weapons. He closed his eyes to the unequal tit-for-tat ratio of French dead to German dead and to the fact that truly innocent Frenchmen were being detained and killed, declaring himself more committed than ever to collaboration with psychopathic killers and oppressors. (The German version of “collaboration” was Zusammenarbeit, “working together.”) According to French sources, between May 1940 and September 1944 a total of 6,000 Frenchmen were massacred (massacrés) by Germans working with their “allies” (most likely the Milice, a Vichy French paramilitary force), 25,000 were shot (fusillés), and 27,000 résistants died during deportation, not to mention the tens of thousands of déportés who died following their incarceration in German concentration camps.
German Atrocities in France and the French Resistance
Above: Oradour-sur-Glane today looking southeast along the main thoroughfare, Rue Desourteaux, earlier lined with bars, cafés, and restaurants. In 1944 only about a quarter of its 1,500 residents lived in town. The rest were in outlying hamlets and farms. On a hot Saturday afternoon on June 10, 200 SS soldiers in half-tracks and trucks drove up unannounced from the St. Julien road (bottom), sealed off the town, and rounded up its inhabitants into a central recreational area. The townspeople were then bombed, shot with automatic weapons, or burned to death. The Germans then set the town ablaze. By about 7 p.m. most of them were gone with the exception of a single German fatality and a guard unit. Photo source: Alan Davidge, “The Execution of Oradour-sur-Glane,” Warfare History Network, Spring 2023.
Left: The church in Oradour-sur-Glane in which, on June 10, 1944, 245 women villagers and visitors and 205 children were burnt to death or shot as they attempted to escape from the clutches of a crazed Waffen-SS unit. Their husbands, sons, and brothers were marched to nearby barns, lined up, and shot, first in their legs to prevent them from moving. The victims were doused in gasoline and the barns and their contents incinerated. One woman and 6 men survived the massacre. The village was partially razed. After the war a new village was built on a nearby site. On the orders of French president Charles de Gaulle the original village has been maintained as a museum and permanent memorial to the cruelty of the Nazi occupation. Today, the village martyr (martyred village) is a tourist destination, complete with maps and guidebooks. Photo taken June 11, 2004.
Right: Wrecked hardware (bicycles, sewing machine, etc.) seven decades later, left as a reminder of the unspeakable barbarity of the German reprisal in Oradour-sur-Glane. An initial judicial investigation by German authorities into the Tulle and Oradour-sur-Glane reprisals, urged on by Field Marshal Erwin Rommel and Pétain’s Vichy French government, was opened, then suspended, in part because many of the perpetrators had been killed in action during the Battle of Normandy. Finally in January 1953 a military tribunal in Bordeaux, France, heard the case against the surviving 65 of the approximately 200 Waffen-SS soldiers who had been involved in the massacres. Only 21 defendants were in court because many of the accused could not be extradited from the new East Germany (German Democratic Republic). On February 1, 1953, with a lone exception all were convicted of war crimes.
Left: During the Allied invasion of Normandy, the Maquis (rural guerrilla bands in Brittany and Southern France) and other groups played an important role in delaying German mobilization. The FFI (Forces Françaises de l’Interieur, French irregulars) blew up railroad tracks and repeatedly attacked German Army equipment and garrison trains on their way to the Channel coast. This photo shows members of the Maquis in La Tresorerie near Boulogne-sur-Mer, Northern France, September 14, 1944.
Right: Resistance members captured by the Milice, a Vichy French paramilitary force, July 1944. By 1944 Milice’s membership may have reached 25,000–35,000, including part-time members, non-combatants, and women, who comprised 15 percent of the membership. Miliciens operated in both the “free zone” (Pétain’s Vichy France) and in the German-occupied zone (zone occupée), including Paris. Many miliciens were imprisoned for treason, executed following courts-martial, or killed by résistants and civilians who revenged themselves in the épuration sauvage (pursuit of Nazi collaborators) that took place after the war’s end.